Girl Comics (2010) #2

Girl comics 2

It’s another terrible issue. Is Marvel trying to say all female creators can do are trite stories? Colleen Coover annoys with her opening…

Oh, wait. The Jill Thompson Inhumans story is fine. It’s predictable to the point I think I’ve read it somewhere before (Lockjaw getting a bath) but the art’s good and the writing’s inoffensive.

The next one is awful—it’s about a superheroine beauty parlor, from Coover with Kathryn Immonem writing. The uncredited letterer screws up the dialogue pacing but it wouldn’t be much better with competent word balloons.

Stephanie Buscema has a weak Doctor Doom two pager.

Faith Erin Hicks’s Nextwave story features a superhero killing teenagers. I guess that’s cool. You know, for a Disney comic. But it’s otherwise weak.

Abby Denson and Emma Vieceli’s superhero personals (starring Mary Jane) is lame.

Finally, Christine Boylan and Cynthia Martin’s Doctor Strange is well-illustrated but poorly written.

Phonogram: The Singles Club (2008) #2

Psc02

Oh, wait, the girl from the first issue isn’t really that terrible and didn’t deserve to be treated so meanly?

Gillen is apparently doing a night at the club from everyone’s perspective, so this issue we get to see how some other guy spent the night. Basically, it was him being depressed over some foreign exchange student who is now gone (either dead or just gone back to Helsinki).

It’s maybe Gillen’s best writing of a character just because he’s not going out of his way to make the guy as annoying or unlikable as possible. He’s just a guy.

Some more great art from McKelvie. It really brings an added dimension to it, since in black and white he’s frequently sparse because of the graphic design approach.

The backups here are filler.

Vieceli’s has some beautiful artwork and succeeds.

Heard’s art is fine in other, there’s just no story.