Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990, Steve Barron)

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles uses Central Park as an establishing shot for an apartment at 11th and Bleecker. I’ll let you Google Map that one.

The film’s worth talking about for four reasons—the amazing animatronics, the editing, the anti-Japanese sentiment and Judith Hoag. It’s also amusing to watch for Sam Rockwell sightings, but that one isn’t so much a discussion point.

For people who care about puppetry and animatronics, the work the Jim Henson workshop does in Turtles is phenomenal. They create five entirely believable creatures. It’s so effective, in fact, I’m glad Josh Pais both did the voice and the costume work for his character… so I can identify him as the film’s worst performance.

There are some terrible performances from the regular actors here, but Pais is atrocious. His characterization seems like a mix between James Cagney and George Jefferson. If Turtles weren’t a stupid movie with a bad script, he’d be the one ruining it.

Switching up the list a bit—Judith Hoag. While Elias Koteas (as her romantic interest) is okay, she’s great opposite all the costumes and animatronic nonsense. She makes the fantastical nature work… at least until her character disappears to give more attention to the lame fight scenes.

The great editing—in the fight scenes and not—makes Turtles mildly tolerable. The anti-Japanese sentiment is bewildering but captivating.

Awful performances from James Saito and Obata Toshirô—the only Japanese actors—don’t help.

Turtles is terrible. Hoag aside, there’s nothing “good.”

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 1 (August 2011)

833451.jpg
I recently read how the in-joke of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles is their origin was a side effect of Daredevil’s origin; subtle homage.

Not so here, in IDW’s relaunch. Instead, here the Turtles and Splinter (and a big bad rabbit) are the result of some genetic experiment. The issue’s split between modern day and flashback. The modern stuff is lame. It’s hard to believe writers Kevin Eastman and Tom Waltz think Splinter’s exposition is good. The lofty, pseudo-Eastern nonsense makes one wish Splinter would get knocked out, just to shut up that narration.

The Turtles themselves are without personality. Eastman and Waltz just don’t have time.

Dan Duncan’s action artwork is nothing special. He’s too raw for IDW’s overproduced book; especially the colors.

But in the flashback, Duncan’s excellent (drawing people, not animal people). The plot’s more interesting too.

So far, Turtles is better without the Turtles.

CREDITS

Writers, Kevin Eastman and Tom Waltz; pencillers, Eastman and Dan Duncan; inker, Duncan; colorist, Ronda Pattison; letterer, Robbie Robbins; editor, Scott Dunbier; publisher, IDW Publishing.