Batman: Year 100 (2006) #2

Bm100 2

About a third of this issue is talking heads. First, it’s unnamed Batman 2039 and his team—including a new Robin, who starts the issue working on a bitchin’ motorcycle for Bats—talking through what led up to last issue’s issue-long chase sequence, and then it’s cop Gordon and his gang looking through the archives for information on “The Bat-Man.”

Both sequences are strange, though for different reasons. The Batman one because creator Paul Pope is trying to avoid doing any character introductions and instead focus on their conversation about the dead cop and Batman’s inability to remember enough details. It’s a briefing with occasional personality (usually from Robin 2039). It’s not interesting, but it’s also not grating like Gordon’s sequence.

So the Gordon sequence. They’re going through the archives—remember, last issue, no one had any idea there was a “Bat-Man” a hundred years ago, and even the modern incarnation was a surprise to Gordon. In Year 100 continuity… Detective Comics #27 is in continuity, something something something in the sixties in continuity, The Dark Knight Returns is in glowing continuity. Then maybe something from Dark Knight Strikes Back. I didn’t read Strikes Back so I don’t know if it’s what Pope’s talking about. The most attention goes to the DKR stuff, which means in Year 100 continuity, Batman in Dark Knight was at least seventy, not fifty-five or whatever. Also, Zorro would be out.

It’d be better if Pope weren’t just overtly winking and nodding to Frank Miller. But, it still wouldn’t be good. No one knows about there being a Batman in Gotham City for eighty years because the records were destroyed. It also means no one in Gotham in 2039 remembers anything from twenty years before. Seems like mass amnesia would have more repercussions.

The other two-thirds of the comic are action procedural. Gordon goes to the crime scene to see what the federal cops are lying to him about; Batman breaks into the federal cop morgue to look at the guy he supposedly killed.

Exquisite art on all of it, though obviously better on the action. Pope doesn’t make the talking heads sequences interesting visually; he matches the monotony and tediousness of the dialogue. Appropriate, but also, why do the scenes if you’re not interested in doing the scenes. Especially since the first issue established Year 100 can run on pure adrenalin. Contriving reasons to be reticent during exposition dumps….

The second half of the comic does a lot to redeem the first, though it’s clear Pope doesn’t actually have a good story, which is foreboding given there are two issues to go.

Batman: Year 100 (2006) #1

Bmy100 1

This first issue of Batman: Year 100 is an all-action issue. It’s the future, so people can get around pretty quickly, including federal cops flying around in, I don’t know, hovercraft. Helicopter cabins without rotors or skids. But the future’s also got its low-tech; the first sequence has a pack of police dogs chasing “The Bat-Man of Gotham” across the rooftops. They’ve got retina cameras to make them futuristic, but initially, it’s just a dog pack chasing the vigilante scene.

Actually, it’s too bad creator Paul Pope doesn’t show how the dogs operate on the rooftops. I’m sure it’d be awesome.

Because even though there’s minimal story, barely any characters, and the most writing comes in the opening and closing “news” briefs (courtesy future Reuters) on the front and back inside covers, Batman: Year 100 is divine. It’s forty-eight pages of detailed, thoughtful, exuberant Pope art. Who cares what it’s about.

The issue sets up Bat-Man a little; he’s been in Gotham long enough to make an ally with the police coroner, but copper Jim Gordon doesn’t know anything about him. The comic’s set in 2039 (a hundred years after Detective Comics #27), and the previous century’s Bat-Man has become an urban legend. No one even believes the new one exists until he gets caught on the various cameras; a federal police officer has been killed, and Bat-Man is the prime suspect.

The comic does get to the investigation. It starts with the dog chase, then a people chase as the federal cops descend on a Gotham building, and cuts to the federal cops in Washington having a slightly comedic bicker session, freaking out about the situation. Lots of great expressions from Pope in that scene. It ends with a special cop being called in, Tibble. That special cop doesn’t hunt Bat-Man yet; he just gives Gordon shit because jurisdiction tropes.

So Pope is, you know, building a narrative. It just doesn’t matter as much as the action. The comic’s about the rush of reading it, of experiencing the movement in Pope’s panels as the Bat-Man and the story hurl forward. Like the opening chase sequences, the issue’s a race, with Pope trying to maintain momentum until the last panel.

I read Year 100 when it came out and remember it being a disappointment overall, but damn if this issue isn’t a thrill.

Oh, and the José Villarrubia colors are gorgeous. The whole thing’s gorgeous.

Batman ’89 (2021) #5

Batman 895

Until this issue, Batman ’89 has been so light on Commissioner Gordon you’d think Pat Hingle’s estate wasn’t letting them use likeness. But he’s got a big part this issue, only for him to come off like a complete asshole. Potentially one who doesn’t like daughter Barbara dating a Black guy but lies to her face about it. There’s only an issue left, so presumably, they’ll be able to rush through it.

In addition to Catwoman’s new costume with the exposed thighs, the most unfilmable part of the comic is Gordon. There are multiple reasons Pat Hingle couldn’t do this part, including the acting required.

Anyway.

This issue has Billy Dee Williams in full “Harvey Two-Face” mode now, flipping the coin to decide various fates. Writer Sam Hamm does a nice job of introducing and executing his first Bat-villain heist—though it does seem very second act and not penultimate issue stuff. Hamm and artist Joe Quinones have a lot of fun with the planning stages, which has Two-Face bringing back the Joker gang and talking through how a supervillain’s goon gang works. In addition, there are some excellent visual nods to Batman 1989 and a fun Dark Knight Returns “cameo.”

The comic’s main plot is Two-Face’s heist planning, with Batman training Robin as one subplot and Barbara Gordon pursuing Harvey as another. Catwoman’s just thrown in—not sure how they would’ve convinced Michelle Pfeiffer to show up for such a small part, but she’s got the most personality in just a couple panels. Hamm’s Selina Kyle is gloriously peculiar. Silly exposed thigh costume or not.

The Robin-in-training sequences are good, with solid banter. You can hear Michael Keaton delivering the lines. Outside Commissioner Gordon’s dialogue, which also has him being drunk and fun at one point, Hamm does a fine job writing for the “cast.”

With only one issue to go, this one’s a little “too late, too much,” with Hamm and Quinones racing and packing, but it’s much better than expected. There’s some nice art from Quinones throughout, and the Batman and Robin banter is a delight, even though there’s not enough of it.

I’m assuming the next issue won’t bungle things too badly, and I hope they get another outing. Though maybe more than six issues; Hamm’s plotting obviously doesn’t work for six.

Batman ’89 (2021) #4

Batman894

I’m verklempt. I wasn’t expecting to be verklempt. But writer Sam Hamm is going for it with Batman ‘89, with artist Joe Quinones going along with all of it—try to make a community march, but in Tim Burton’s Gotham City, you got it—and this issue might be where the elevation is permanent. Hamm’s taken this goofy, craven comic book tchotchke and made it special.

And not even because it made me verklempt. I got verklempt in the opening, which is about many Black Gothamites marching after Harvey Dent’s injury and resulting hospitalization. They’re marching in support of Harvey and his renewed mission for a more equitable Gotham City. Commissioner Gordon—mostly off-page—has guaranteed them the cops will be there to help, not hinder. All the church leaders are there; the news is there; it’d take a real asshole to screw it up.

That asshole is Lieutenant Harvey Bullock, who’s a racist piece of shit and is going to attack all the marchers and toss them in jail because it’ll teach them to behave. I’m still unsure who, if anyone, Quinones and Hamm have in mind for the Bullock “casting.”

But then Bullock’s attempts to sabotage the march go wrong when Robin shows up, distributing spray paint and smoke bombs and giving the marchers a chance. Now, since it’s a comic book set in a movie universe, the cops are only using rubber bullets—which are not non-lethal and quite dangerous—so there’s still little danger to the marchers. But thanks to Robin, there’s enough time for Gordon to show up for Pat Hingle’s one-panel cameo. I think it’s got to be a joke about how little Hingle’s in the movies.

Or maybe his estate’s litigious.

Anyway.

After that opening, it’s incredible Hamm’s going to try to flex some more, and flex he does. First, the Harvey in the hospital subplot, which involves Barbara Gordon. She’ll get her own subplot with Selina Kyle (who doesn’t look much like Michelle Pfeiffer, but it’s still cool to see professional, not boss-murdery Selina in action); they don’t quite pass Bechdel, but it’s more because the system’s patriarchal and sexist. Like, they actually don’t have anything else to talk about in their scene.

We get some insight into Harvey and Two-Face, who argue, which is interesting. There are also a bunch of Superman: The Movie homages with Harvey’s escape from the cops and eventual lair, which is neat. It’d have been really cute in a movie in 1995 or whatever.

But the other big swing and hit from Hamm is introducing (Not Tim) Drake Winston to Bruce Wayne. Drake’s pretty sure Wayne’s Batman, for a bunch of good reasons—including some funny ones—and he’s trying to suss out his suspicions. Meanwhile, thanks to Alfred, Bruce has just discovered his great grand-daddy put Drake’s great grand-daddy out of business on a shitty white man whim once upon a time. So there’s this uncomfortable depth to the relationship immediately, even before it turns into Michael Keaton—even a dramatic Michael Keaton—playing straight man in comedy scenes. But then it worked out perfectly.

There are only two more issues, and who knows how this book has sold but damn, I hope they get another one. I’m not familiar enough with this genre—which, for the longest time, was solely the purview of Stars Wars and Treks—Hamm and Quinones seem primed to fully legitimize it as an artistic endeavor.

Batman ’89 (2021) #3

Batman '89 #3

Did the Michelle Pfeiffer/Tim Burton Catwoman movie never get made because she refused to wear the new outfit from Batman ’89? Or are the costume designs on the comic just going to be wanting overall. Robin seems inevitable, and I’m concerned.

But the banter between Batman and Catwoman—Michael Keaton and Pfeiffer—is kind of exactly what I’d always wished it would be. Their rooftop rendezvous is half-great, then a quarter hints at a reveal, and the last quarter is set up for next issue’s A plot. It’s a little too efficient when it needs to be prolonged, especially since writer Sam Hamm has spent the entire issue teasing the scene.

The issue’s got a bunch of action at the start, only not really. Billy Dee Williams goes from star of the comic to the “And” credit after we get the ’89 origin of Two-Face. Sorry, Harvey Two-Face; I wonder if they’ll go there. Worse, Harvey receives a couple dream sequences. Now, artist Joe Quinones does a fabulous job with most of this issue—Catwoman’s new costume aside—and really shows off in the banter sequences between Bruce Wayne and Alfred (and their cat), and then Bruce and (Tim) Drake (Winston) Robin (Zeddemore) or whatever his name’s going to end up being, but he does not do a great dream sequence. Maybe, you know, Tim Burton would’ve done it well or whatever, but in the comic… it looks like a rushed riff on the High Anxiety VHS box cover. Not really worthy of Billy Dee Williams’s Two-Face origin story.

Actually, given the villain origin sequences in Batman and Batman Returns… it’s even more of a bummer. But they may still have time to fix it. I was worried when I thought it was issue four, and there were only two more left, but it’s the third, and there’s possibly time. Hamm and Quinones do a good job packing in content, but they could obviously use another five pages. It feels like a surprisingly good comic book adaptation of a non-existent movie, which is probably the best approach.

I’d be more enthusiastic for next issue if there’d been another page of Keaton and Pfeiffer flirting and less dream sequence. And maybe at least an appearance from Commissioner Gordon, who’s strangely absent like Pat Hingle’s likeness isn’t under contract or something.

But Bruce and Drake are potentially a fun duo. As ever, fingers crossed they pull ’89 off.

Batman ’89 (2021) #2

Batman 89 Cv2 7ad623c3fe30440aaf2999c2a26da03c

So it’s not Batman ‘89, it’s Batman ’93? As in, set after Batman Returns… is it just Sam Hamm’s Batman Forever? If so, it’s still okay. I just wasn’t expecting the returning character at the end of the issue. I also wasn’t expecting Hamm to do a deep cut to the original script—and the Craig Shaw Gardner novelization—of Batman. At one point, Bruce Wayne needs to costume up, and he doesn’t have his Batsuit, so he goes into his trunk, dons a ski mask, and charges into battle, which is one of those moments from the novelization I remember since it never comes close to happening in the movie.

In fact, outside the first scene, there’s no Batman action. Instead, it’s Harvey Dent coming to terms with being a Black man in the white establishment while trying to address police violence against Black people in Gotham. And Bruce Wayne realizing there are limitations to vigilantism, and maybe he should spend his money helping instead of just assuming he’s beating up the right people.

Hamm’s script goes in very hard on protests against police violence and structural racism, and so on. It’s impossible to imagine it in 1989, 1993, or 1995. Batman ’89 is of a moment, and it’s this one. It’s post-White Knight, it’s post-“Batgirl of Burnside”—Burnside’s still pre-gentrified, though Barbara Gordon isn’t a kid here, she’s Harvey Dent’s plus one. The comic talks around whether or not Dent doesn’t want to be seen with her because she’s white or because she’s Commissioner Gordon’s daughter, as he finds himself working for a community instead of trying to police it out of existence. Hamm’s writing has got its limits, and he’s bumping into them over and over, but he’s trying.

Joe Quinones’s art is excellent. There’s only that first scene with the Batsuit reverence, but all of the art is very carefully done. The expressions are just right for Bruce Wayne to imply Michael Keaton without going too far; Quinones’s scales back the almost caricature take from last issue. Michael Gough’s Alfred gets some good scenes. Given many of the characters have real-life analogs, I wish they’d “cast” the rest of the comic, too, just because Quinones does so well.

The issue also introduces Robin, who will be an entirely new character—unless he gets a “Robin John Blake” moment or whatever—and Hamm’s making another wide swing with him. Not just a Black Robin, but one very aware of being a Black man in a hostile, racist environment. Batman movies, of course, always go overboard with sidekicks and villains, they just can’t help themselves (action figures don’t sell themselves), and Hamm’s getting together a very full cast.

But he’s also taking the opportunity seriously, and he’s definitely working to keep up with Quinones’s dynamite work. Batman ’89/’93 is heading into act two… I really hope they’ve got it figured.

Batman ’89 (2021) #1

Batman 89 1 Cover

I haven’t read any of the previous DC comics sequels to their TV or movie properties—I think it’s just been TV properties, right (“Batman” and “Wonder Woman”)—but I’m certainly sympathetic to the proposition. I did, after all, read the ostensible canon IDW Star Trek: The JJ Abrams Years series for a while.

But Batman ’89… I’m actually unsure how to unpack all the nostalgia and fan service. It’s not just “another” Michael Keaton (more on that casting in a bit) Batman; it’s Billy Dee Williams as Two-Face.

Or, a Harvey Dent who looks enough like Billy Dee Williams. There are a few things in the issue I don’t think they’d ever have done in a nineties movie, like have a Black Harvey Dent confront how he’s moved on up. Because so far, Batman ’89 is Dent’s story. There’s a little Bruce Wayne, a little Batman, but the Dent story is the A-plot.

A couple things first.

“Michael Keaton” Bruce Wayne. Joe Quinones’s art in this issue is excellent. The beginning, which has Batman stalking Harvey Dent for no reason actually, gave me shudders; it’s when I realized how good this comic felt. Even before getting to Sam Hamm’s on-point Batman dialogue. But the Bruce Wayne. It looks like a Mad Magazine caricature of Michael Keaton. So much it makes you wonder if he’s got residuals due for likeness, and they wanted to get away with it on a technicality. It doesn’t really matter yet—and might never matter, depending on how the series (which runs six issues) goes—but it’s not great.

The rest is pretty great. Yes, the whited-out Batman eyes don’t seem right with the Batman 1989 costume, and Quinones and Hamm’s Commissioner Gordon (ostensibly based on Pat Hingle) is very much not Pat Hingle. The Commissioner Gordon is better than Pat Hingle could ever be.

Quinones’s “production design” is perfect, moving between movie locations, creating new ones, and introducing old comics homages. The secret origin of the Batcave penny is here, even though it never made the movie Batcave.

The story’s set soon after the first movie. Once the city realized having a vigilante on call would lead to property damage (nice to see Samm kept up on Batman comics enough to read White Knight), Gordon and Batman are working together on the down-low. That arrangement bothers district attorney Dent, who decides to break it up, his engagement to Barbara Gordon be darned. Well, Barbara seems to support Harvey against her dad, so not so darned.

There’s a good backstory for the lucky coin, there’s socially conscious superheroing they’d never have done in one of the movies, and there’s a surprise character. The bad guys so far are leftover Joker thugs, which tracks.

Batman ’89 is a solid comic with all the right strings for the target demographic. Maybe not the comic of the decade, but it certainly legitimizes the concept of professional fan-fic.

Batman Versus Predator (1991-92)

Bvp

Batman Versus Predator, in case the title doesn’t give it away, is bad. It’s real bad. It could be worse, sure, but it’s real bad.

It doesn’t open terribly—sure, the Kubert Brothers art is pretty bland from go, but the subject matter is at least sort of interesting (compared to where it goes later). And writer Dave Gibbons (who doesn’t just overwrite the comic, he badly overwrites it) has some style for the opening. He juxtaposes the Predator attacking some old guy and his dog with the Gotham City championship boxing match. The former isn't important (other than it's a little weird the Predator is attacking a junkyard watchman), but the latter turns out to be the whole comic. See, the Predator isn’t initially interested in hunting Batman or even (armed) criminals or (armed) cops. It’s out to take out the championship boxers.

Because they’re champions. Says so on the news. The Predator watches a lot of news in Batman Versus Predator and repeats sound bytes to make dialogue. Because Gibbons is incapable of writing an action sequence without a bunch of stupid recycled sound bytes the Predator has picked up somewhere. At one point, it seems like the comic would be at least somewhat better without their constant addition. But then, once the Kuberts never get any better—they can’t make the Predator versus the criminals interesting, they can’t even make Batman versus the Predator interesting, though it’d probably be hard to do given the big showdown is in the woods surrounding Wayne Manor. But there are times when it doesn’t seem like Batman Versus Predator isn’t going to be a complete waste of time.

Sadly, all of them are in the first issue (of three). And by the end of the first issue, it seems kind of unlikely the book is ever going to turn around.

Most of the comic, overall, is about the crooked businessmen and gangsters who run Gotham (and the boxers) getting wiped out by the Predator. It kills them because… it knows they’re swinging dick criminals and it came to town to hunt some white collar looking criminals. Then it takes on Batman and puts him down for the count—there’s this terribly ineffective device where Gibbons and the Kuberts have a single panel showing Batman getting home all cut up at the bottom of pages while above the main action with the cops or crooks or whatever plays out.

Because Jim Gordon’s got a big part. Not sure why he doesn’t try to take out the Predator himself as the Kuberts draw him just as buff as Batman, which is considerable because they’re Batman is super buff. So big and buff it’s like, obviously you need some meaty muscle guy like Ben Affleck for that part.

But you wouldn’t want to see Batman Versus Predator: The Movie with Batfleck or anyone else, because the only thing the comic succeeds at showing is how bad it would be. Even though it’s about two “characters”—Batman arguably has less personality than the sound byte spouting Predator here—who are known for their wonderful toys, there’s not much competition.

You’d think after fighting aliens since the fifties or whenever they first showed up in a Batman comic, Bats would have some better ideas than he comes up with here. Nope. There are a couple times in action scenes where it’s like… why did that work? The Predator is scared of cars?

The big action finale has Batman in special armor, which looks like the suit from the end of Batman Forever, though I don’t think the Kuberts got a thank you, and then he has a sword at some point. Because armor and swords and whatever.

Batman Versus Predator is pretty dumb, even for a comic called Batman Versus Predator. I’ll bet if you bought this comic back in 1990 thinking it would resemble Watchmen in some way because of Gibbons, you were pissed as all hell. Though, as someone who bought it back in the day—at age twelve—I recall being shameless about it.

I shouldn’t have been shameless. I should’ve acutely felt the shame.

Batman: White Knight (2017) #8

Bwk08

White Knight is fine. Murphy finishes it fine. The art is great, there’s some really cool action–imagine if a Schumacher Batman movie vehicle setpiece were good–and the dialogue’s occasionally really strong.

It’s not great. The sequel setup stuff is weak and a copout as far as character work goes. There are other copouts on the character work; Barbara and Dick are accessories, so’s Gordon. There’s nothing to them.

Other than the art. And Murphy’s love of all things Batman.

After dawdling through multiple issues, Murphy runs out of time in this one. Not just the sequel setup nonsense, but also with the action sequence. Nightwing gets lost. And the action sequence develops to something Murphy could really go wild with and he doesn’t.

It’s too bad White Knight wasn’t great. The art’s great and there’s some really cool things about it, but it didn’t achieve that initial promise of a new great Batman comic. Murphy should have tempered his ambitions, as they all turned out to be empty anyway.

Batman: White Knight (2017) #7

Bwk07

Murphy really likes deus ex machina plot devices. He uses three or five of them in White Knight #7.

Given where the series goes, I’m not sure he really needed eight issues–this issue seems like the always intended, not drawn out, penultimate issue. There’s a lot going on, a lot of crowded rooms with exposition, a lot of rushed character moments, a handful of revelations. Murphy recenters White Knight on Batman this issue, which almost comes as a surprise. Whether or not it’s successful is going to depend on the finale–Batman makes some hard promises as he gets out of Arkham and teamed with Jack Napier. Murphy’s going to have to keep some of them.

He can’t just have it turn out Thomas Wayne was a secret agent fighting the Nazis. The series’s early success came from Murphy’s willingness to reveal red herrings to be real herrings.

There’s a lot of awesome art–including the “Batman” TV show Batmobile getting some action–but the panels are mostly tiny. Grizzled Batman gets way too many big panels while Murphy’s gorgeous design work gets relegated to little ones. It might be Batman’s comic again, but it doesn’t mean he’s the most interesting thing to see. I mean, Jake Napier’s Jokering out uncontrollably, which Murphy does like a hybrid homage to Bolland and Sienkiewicz. It’s awesome art.

So Batman: White Knight might make it. Not the heights it initially promised, but some significant ones.

It’ll probably make a good trade. It could be a great movie (but not one of those animated ones… and most certainly not a live action one with Ben Affleck and Jared Leto).