blogging by Andrew Wickliffe

Desk Set (1957, Walter Lang)

Despite being an adaptation of a stage play and having one main set, Desk Set shouldn’t be stagy. The single main location–and its importance–ought to be able to outweigh the staginess. Desk Set does not, however, succeed in not being stagy. It puts off being stagy for quite a while, but not forever, which is too bad.

The fault lies with director Lang. He moves between three camera setups on the main set–the research department for a television network (FBC but in NBC’s building). When it comes time to change everything up in the third act, Lang doesn’t change his camera defaults and it really does knock the film down for its finale. Desk Set was already going a tad long–not good considering it runs just over 100 minutes–and the film needed a strong finish. A really strong finish.

It gets a tepid one instead. Worse, it gets multiple tepid finishes. It’s a shame because the film’s often a lot of fun. Spencer Tracy is a mysterious efficency expert sent to Katharine Hepburn’s research department to do… something. Desk Set takes its time revealing Tracy’s assignment, not even providing clues while he’s rooting around the department, often crawling around on the floor. It’s a quirky part; Tracy’s socially awkward, absentminded, and entirely lovable. At least to the audience. The viewer isn’t worried about getting fired.

In addition to Hepburn, there’s her staff who’s got to worry about getting the pink slip. Joan Blondell, Sue Randall, and Dina Merrill. Randall and Merrill don’t get particularly good parts. They get stuff to do, they get a lot of scenes–the film’s mostly set in the workplace after all–but there’s nothing to them. Randall opens the movie trying to get a better price on a dress and it’s more than she gets to do than in the rest of the picture. Merrill doesn’t get anywhere near as much to do. It’s too bad, they’re both extremely likable.

Though likable is what Desk Set is always going for. Take Gig Young, for instance. He’s Hepburn’s boss and her consistently–but not constantly–frisky paramour. Even though he’s an absolute jerk, he’s fairly likable. I mean, he gets everyone Christmas presents; he didn’t need to get everyone Christmas presents.

Blondell gets the best part in the supporting cast. She’s Hepburn’s confidant, although only sporadically and less after the first act. The first act is a very long day at the network, starting with Tracy arriving, then meeting Hepburn, then the focus moves to Hepburn and her strange encounters with Tracy. The ingrained momentum of the day doesn’t keep up after the first act. Desk Set moves over to summary and slowing down for big sequences.

There are some lovely big sequences, like Tracy and Hepburn getting caught in the rain and having an impromptu dinner date. All of their scenes one-on-one are good–at least, until the third act–with Tracy playing somewhat coy. He’s incredibly impressed with Hepburn and doesn’t seem to know what to do with that admiration. If the third act were stronger, it’d become a problem when Tracy’s crappy to his own employee (Neva Patterson). But it’s not because by that time, Desk Set is about ten minutes overdue for an ending.

Phoebe and Henry Ephron’s script is fine. Leon Shamroy’s photography is decent. Robert L. Simpson’s editing is too jumpy but it seems like director Lang didn’t give him enough to work with. Again, makes no sense since there’s basically just the one location. It’s inexplicable how Lang can’t get enough coverage for it.

Tracy’s great, Hepburn’s better. She energetically embraces her part’s particularities–like reciting full poems or elaborating on her memory shortcuts. She does a lot with those moments. And Lang seems to get it because he just lets the camera watch her deliver the impossibly wordy lines.

It’s just a shame Hepburn’s character becomes a complete moron whenever Young shows up. She does his work for him–her abject deference to such a tool is a big disconnect. Though it does give Blondell some good lines when she’s chiding Hepburn about it.

Tracy and Hepburn make Desk Set, but not even their ability and charm can make up for director Lang. He’s too concerned with making it feel wide–it’s Cinemascope–and fitting as many actors in frame as possible. The third act in the script is problematic too, but better direction might have gotten it through.

9 responses to “Desk Set (1957, Walter Lang)”

  1. Not one of my favorite Tracy-Hepburn movies. I think you are right — Walter Lang’s unimaginative direction is mostly to blame … The movie needed someone like Billy Wilder.

    1. Wilder would’ve been amazing.

  2. Even though I haven’t seen this film all the way through, I like what the previous commenter said about Billy Wilder directing it. Many reviews I’ve read have the same impressions as yours, Andrew, and it makes you wonder what might have been if someone else had been directing.

    However, I enjoyed your review very much!

    1. Thanks! I was wondering, going into it, why I’d never heard of it…

  3. I’ve seen the film, but honestly I don’t remember much from it. :/ I think my favourite scene was the dinner outside. Quite an amusing mess! I liked how your review is honest, but also share the good sides of this film. I agree, it’s not perfect, but it’s not completely bad either. Maybe it needed more dynamism.

    1. That outdoor scene is so good. More than anything else it seemed to suit Hepburn and Tracy’s strengths playing off one another!

      1. I agree!

  4. Le Magalhaes

    I liked he film, in special the outdoor scene. Yet, I think the end was flawed and things wrapped up too quick. It had more potential, but at least it’s here to be remembered as the first movie the duo Tracy-Hepburn did in color.
    Don’t forget to read my contribution to the blogathon! 🙂

  5. Thanks for joining in on the blogathon, and I’m really sorry for the late reply. Unfortunately, I’ve been ill. “Desk Set” is one of my favorite Kate an Spence movies, but I do agree with you about the ending. I would have liked to have seen a bit more rather then it ending abruptly.

    By the way, I’ve just announced another blogathon. I’d love to invite you to participate. Here is the link below.

Leave a Reply

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: