blogging by Andrew Wickliffe

Popeye 4 (August 2012)

875701The Popeye feature suffers a little from lack of intelligent characters. For a second, I thought Castor Oyl would prove smart; he does not. Wimpy does show intelligence… and never gets recognized for it. But Langridge never loses track of him, which is sort of a reward. Langridge loses track of everyone at some point in the story.

It’s a very busy tale of a small (microscopic) kingdom Popeye and friends have to save. There’s lots of dialogue; Langridge wraps the exposition into the jokes beautifully. It’s well-written, it’s just a war story mixed with a detective story mixed with Popeye. It’s amazing Langridge is able to keep track of it at all.

The Sappo backup is a beautifully simple day at the beach. The jokes are universally strong, Langridge paces them all carefully, Neely’s artwork is lovely.

It’s a good comic, the backup’s just stronger than the feature.


Good Night, Blozo!; artist and letterer, Vince Musacchia; colorist, Luke McDonnell. Hero of the Beach; artist, colorist and letterer, Tom Neely. Writer, Roger Langridge; editor, Ted Adams, Craig Yoe and Clizia Gussoni; publisher, IDW Publishing.

One response to “Popeye 4 (August 2012)”

  1. vernon wiley

    While I agree with your assessment of the back up strip being stronger, well that seems like a occupational hazard of working with classic characters like Popeye. His story has been told so many times, and has such strict perimeters to work with, I’m amazed Landridge can come up with a story I can get interested in at all. Keeping it short and sweet helps, and the consistent “digs” of the personalities here are icing on the cake.

Leave a Reply

Blog at