Wildfire 4 (October 2014)

Wildfire #4Wildfire gets across the finish line with a lot of problems. Hawkins still manages to sell the issue, but he’s got some questionable moments throughout. Besides supporting cast members ending up dead, things go pretty well for the protagonists this issue and everything sort of works out. There’s even a time lapse towards the end of the issue to get out of character development.

And that omission is something of a blessing in disguise because Sejic’s art looks like bad cels from a cheap CG kids movie. Like a direct-to-video Disney knockoff. Something about the way she draws the characters this issue, their expressions… it’s like 101 Dalmatians or something.

There’s just enough of Hawkins’s attention to detail to get the story done. He reminds of better moments, better realizations. The series probably needed another issue to really get the ending done well.

But it’s still somewhat successful.

B 

CREDITS

Writer, Matt Hawkins; artist, Linda Sejic; letterer, Troy Peteri; editor, Betsy Gonia; publisher, Top Cow Productions.

Tales of Honor 5 (October 2014)

Tales of Honor #5There’s some great stuff in the issue, specifically where Hawkins describes how space battle works between ships. He does some quick, but detailed exposition, then carefully maneuvers the dialogue to reinforce what the reader already has passing familiarity with. It works out very well.

And the issue, which takes place over an hour or two, works out. It’s tense and compelling, with Hawkins never giving any comic relief. There’s no relief valve for the tension, except maybe through the art, which is never good enough to transport the reader to the battle. There are some good establishing shots in the issue, for double-page spreads, but it’s otherwise the same weak Jeong art as always.

The problems come at the end of the issue, with Hawkins wrapping things up too quickly. He’s been telling a story directly related to the bookends and not clear enough about the important connections throughout.

B 

CREDITS

On Basilisk Station, Part Five; writer, Matt Hawkins; artists, Sang-Il Jeong and Linda Sejic; letterer, Troy Peteri; editor, Besty Gonia; publisher, Top Cow Productions.

Wildfire 3 (August 2014)

Wildfire #3Sejic’s art is a lot better for about half the issue. Instead of doing the CG shading on characters faces, she just colors them. All of a sudden Wildfire looks like animation cels, but it works. Sejic apparently does give her characters expressions, but then the complicated coloring ruins them.

For a lot of this issue, when she’s not doing the CG depth, the expressions work. It’s rather a nice change.

Hawkins goes full Irwin Allen this issue–along with Michael Bay by bringing in the military and starting the countdown to further disaster clock. But it all works. Somehow Hawkins is able to take the most obvious, familiar disaster story tropes and make them feel entirely fresh. Even his characters aren’t original, but something about his presentation immediately deepens them, immediately makes them sympathetic.

Hawkins is a fantastic comic book writer, simply fantastic.

And Wildfire continues to exceed.

Great stuff.

B+ 

CREDITS

Writer, Matt Hawkins; artist, Linda Sejic; letterer, Troy Peteri; editor, Betsy Gonia; publisher, Top Cow Productions.

Tales of Honor 4 (August 2014)

Tales of Honor #4Hawkins is one cruel writer. Until now, he’s always done an excellent job making Tales of Honor an engaging read, but this issue he works out comic book action tension better than maybe anyone ever has before. He makes the comic a page turner, using long expository paragraphs to pace the reader’s attention.

He’s able to get all this tension even after he’s done an odd jumping on recap of the series–and cast–to date. That recap lulls the reader into a relaxed approach to the comic. It also tells the reader most of the cast is okay, since the protagonist is narrating these memories from ten years in the future.

So basically, Hawkins makes it harder for himself. And then he shoots past any possible expectations. This issue is phenomenally plotted.

Unfortunately, there’s also terrible CG art from Jeong. It’s too bad Honor doesn’t have visuals to match the writing.

B 

CREDITS

On Basilisk Station, Part Four; writer, Matt Hawkins; artists, Sang-Il Jeong and Linda Sejic; letterer, Troy Peteri; editor, Besty Gonia; publisher, Top Cow Productions.

Wildfire 2 (July 2014)

Wildfire #2The second issue of Wildfire ties back to the beginning of the first issue–Los Angeles aflame. This issue explains more about how it happens, with Hawkins even taking the time to cut to the fire starting. He doesn’t really need to make the cut–he spends the rest of the issue establishing the characters, including newscasters who could cover it.

And everyone sees the fire pretty quick, it does spread like, well, wildfire.

Hawkins’s ability to get all the science while still moving his characters forward, not to mention rapidly accelerating the crisis, is what makes Wildfire so good. It never reads too fast, even though Hawkins moves fast through the events. Again, there’s a lot of science, which might cause a natural slowdown.

The only problem is Sejic’s computer art. She has this style of a cartoonish–if detailed–character against a glossy, computer generated background. It frequently distracts from the story.

B+ 

CREDITS

Writer, Matt Hawkins; artist, Linda Sejic; letterer, Troy Peteri; editor, Betsy Gonia; publisher, Top Cow Productions.

Wildfire 1 (June 2014)

Wildfire #1Wildfire seems to a science thriller. It’s hard to say so far–writer Matt Hawkins gives the reader a glimpse of the titular disaster and then backtracks a few days, presumably to show now the event came to pass.

He’s got Linda Sejic on art and she’s doing sort of a digital cartooning thing. I say sort of because she’s trying real hard not to be cartoonish but it comes through every once in a while, especially during the character development scenes. But it’s relatively competent–there are some blurring effects she uses to cover not doing full detail and those are annoying–but Hawkins’s script is outstanding.

The setup has a lot to do with the controversy over GMO as food stuffs, but real human failings leading to the science thriller aspects.

Hopefully Hawkins can keep up the balance between tension and character development; it’s a rather impressive start.

B+ 

CREDITS

Writer, Matt Hawkins; artist, Linda Sejic; letterer, Troy Peteri; editor, Betsy Gonia; publisher, Top Cow Productions.

Tales of Honor 3 (June 2014)

Tales of Honor #3Hawkins does such a good job with the pacing–the way he’s able to split the story off into scenes with auxiliary characters and have his protagonist narrate from her side makes Tales of Honor something special. Only this time Hawkins doesn’t have a natural stopping point; he goes for a hard cliffhanger but it’s got to do with a mission, not the commander or the speaking cast.

It cuts down on the effectiveness. Also problematic is that Jeong art. It’s so painfully digital and so uninventive, it needs Hawkins’s plotting and narration (presumably from the source novel) to keep things moving. But the finale has the aliens and Jeong is terrible at the living things.

Still, the mid-section plot development and the character development are just phenomenal and keep Honor compelling on multiple levels. Hawkins just needs to stop leaving his main cast off page for the cliffhangers.

B- 

CREDITS

On Basilisk Station, Part Three; writer, Matt Hawkins; artists, Sang-Il Jeong and Linda Sejic; letterer, Troy Peteri; editor, Besty Gonia; publisher, Top Cow Productions.

Tales of Honor 2 (April 2014)

Tales of Honor #2Something about Hawkins's presentation of facts–the way he uses his protagonist to narrate her past from her present, it makes Tales of Honor very palatable. There are a lot of absurd details, like how the protagonist has the psychic cat who she keeps with her. And takes with her on diplomatic meetings.

But Hawkins sells it, because the comic never refers to other sci-fi. It's always set in its own thing, which is probably a benefit to being an adaptation not just of a novel, but a series of novels. Hawkins can work in the texture.

Speaking of texture, it's amazing I read this comic not just because I don't read complicated sci-fi, but because I loathe the art from Sang-Il Jeong. Either in an attempt to seem futuristic or just save on traditional artist, the whole thing is CGI. The figures are atrocious, animals worse.

Still, it works out.

B- 

CREDITS

On Basilisk Station, Part Two; writer, Matt Hawkins; artists, Sang-Il Jeong and Linda Sejic; letterer, Troy Peteri; editor, Besty Gonia; publisher, Top Cow Productions.

Tales of Honor 1 (March 2014)

F20cd20f 3dfe 4193 ad92 a4609e0a0fe4I have one quibble with Tales of Honor is how Jung-Geun Yoon draws the wildlife. Yoon’s sequential art is very stylized, digital painting, which works great for space battles and not too bad for the people. The conversations are mostly in medium shots so no too static faces delivering dialogue. But the protagonist has a pet cat (it’s not just a pet, it’s a soul-bonded thing but who cares) and Yoon can’t draw that cat. It looks like an Egyptian statue.

Writer Matt Hawkins has quite a bit of material to build on–the series is based on a science fiction novel series–and everything is well-executed. The protagonist is sympathetic but not exactly likable. Hawkins doesn’t give the reader to opportunity to get to know any supporting cast; arguably he hasn’t established one yet.

Tales of Honor’s off to a strong, confident start. It’s good stuff.

B 

CREDITS

On Basilisk Station, Part One; writer, Matt Hawkins; artists, Jung-Geun Yoon and Linda Sejic; colorist, Yoon; letterer, Troy Peteri; editor, Besty Gonia; publisher, Top Cow Productions.