Briefly, TV (3 September 2025)

Alien: Earth (2025) s01e04 “Observation” D: Ugla Hauksdóttir. S: Sydney Chandler, Alex Lawther, Essie Davis, Samuel Blenkin, Babou Ceesay, Adarsh Gourav, Timothy Olyphant. Strong comeback kicks off the science, espionage, manipulation, deceit, and danger arcs, all entwined and engaging. It also reveals it doesn’t matter if Lawther can’t deliver: Chandler, Olyphant, and Davis are giving the only real performances. Everyone else is tediously mid. It’s fine as long as the one of the trio’s there, however. EARTH’s Michael Crichton’s ALIENS, but sure.

Alien: Earth (2025) s01e05 “In Space, No One…” D: Noah Hawley. S: Babou Ceesay. Hawley’s back directing (and writing) with a breathtaking homage to the 1979 ALIEN, albeit far more STAR WARS-aware than the original. It’s also Ceesay’s profile episode; we find out his tragic backstory, which has multiple reveals, as the flashback reveals what happened aboard the crashing ship before it crashes. Very smart, very well-directed, very safe.

All Creatures Great & Small (2020) s05e02 “Holding the Baby” [2024] D: Brian Percival. S: Nicholas Ralph, Samuel West, Anna Madeley, Rachel Shenton, James Anthony-Rose, Imogen Clawson, Tony Pitts. Everyone gets something to do–Ralph tries to learn how to be a dad while on a vet call (with Anthony-Rose along), Shenton and sister Clawson catch up (with dad Pitts about), and West and Madeley run into complications with her Home Guard supervisor, guest star Jeremy Swift. Shenton’s arc’s maybe the best, but they’re all real good.

All Creatures Great & Small (2020) s05e03 “Homecoming” [2024] D: Stewart Svaasand. S: Nicholas Ralph, Samuel West, Anna Madeley, Rachel Shenton, Callum Woodhouse, Imogen Clawson, Tony Pitts. The show has to resolve one of its great unresolved plot threads, and does so with aplomb. Amidst that additional chaos, the household is already preparing for Ralph and Shenton’s baby’s christening, which has brought family in town. Shenton and mother-in-law Gabriel Quigley have an awkward time together. Plus a couple fun, gentle veterinary cases.

All Creatures Great & Small (2020) s05e04 “Uninvited Guests” [2024] D: Stewart Svaasand. S: Nicholas Ralph, Samuel West, Anna Madeley, Rachel Shenton, Callum Woodhouse, James Anthony-Rose, Patricia Hodge. Woodhouse is trying to adjust to being back home and isn’t particularly pleased brother West is indifferent to his discomfort sharing his room with Anthony-Rose. But, first, snake-hunting. Meanwhile, Ralph’s having his own adjustment as people keep asking about his medical discharge. Great episode for Woodhouse. Hodge also figures in with a nice arc. Excellent episode.

My Life Is Murder (2019) s05e04 “Top Two Inches” [2025] D: . S: Lucy Lawless, Ebony Vagulans. Awesome–season best, in the series best–episode has Lawless and Vagulans crashing a trivia night for the Auckland elite. The intrigue plays out not quite real-time but tightly consecutively, involves a returning pest (Benedict Wall), and gives guest star Marta Dusseldorp an excellent part. Especially when opposite Lawless. Great performances all around. The format really works.

My Life Is Murder (2019) s05e05 “Thirteen O’Clock” [2025] D: . S: Lucy Lawless, Ebony Vagulans. Very fun, often cute episode has Lawless and Vagulans investigating a mysterious death at a mysterious party at a toy maker’s mysterious mansion. The investigation is all about unraveling an unrelated secret, so there are lots of hijinks. There’s also a creepy doll, a romantic subplot for Vagulans, and… well, not much else. It’s briskly and assuredly executed.

Briefly, TV (25 August 2025)

Alien: Earth (2025) s01e01 “Neverland” D: Noah Hawley. S: Sydney Chandler, Alex Lawther, Essie Davis, Samuel Blenkin, Babou Ceesay, Adarsh Gourav, Timothy Olyphant. The ALIEN franchise gets a Disney-fied horror, action, sci-fi Prestige Format television show, set just before the first movie. Creator, teleplay writer, and showrunner and (this episode’s) director Hawley’s take is homage-heavy, but all very thoughtfully done. There are a handful of plotlines (and characters for each), which will inevitably congeal as the season progresses.

Alien: Earth (2025) s01e02 “Mr. October” D: Dana Gonzales. S: Sydney Chandler, Alex Lawther, Essie Davis, Samuel Blenkin, Babou Ceesay, Adarsh Gourav, Timothy Olyphant. Not many surprises–until cliffhanger’s “ALIEN monster acts differently than ever before”–but solidly okay. The acting helps–Chandler and Olyphant are outstanding as the main synthetics, while writer Noah Hawley hovers between deft (the main cast isn’t ALIEN food) and safe (Hawley’s very deliberately focusing the audience’s concern). But is it much ado about nothing?

Alien: Earth (2025) s01e03 “Metamorphosis” D: Dana Gonzales. S: Sydney Chandler, Alex Lawther, Essie Davis, Samuel Blenkin, Babou Ceesay, Adarsh Gourav, Timothy Olyphant. After resolving the cliffhanger (with more new ALIEN behavior), the episode deemphasizes Chandler and wanders amongst the characters, recovering from their adventure. On one hand, Lawther is also deemphasized and he’s–politely–ineffectual. Impolitely, he might crash the show with his performance. Olyphant’s great. It seems early for a bridging episode, especially such an inert one. Where’s the show?

All Creatures Great & Small (2020) s05e01 “To All Our Boys” [2024] D: Brian Percival. S: Nicholas Ralph, Samuel West, Anna Madeley, Rachel Shenton, James Anthony-Rose, Patricia Hodge. The war’s still on, but things at home are finding a new normal, especially with a baby and a baby vet around. Meanwhile, Ralph’s adventures are either stranger than fiction or just very well-threaded fiction. Madeley’s subplot about getting more involved with the war effort–and her identity as a (war not animal) vet–is outstanding stuff.

The Gilded Age (2022) s03e05 “A Different World” [2025] D: Deborah Kampmeier. S: Carrie Coon, Morgan Spector, Louisa Jacobson, Denée Benton, Taissa Farmiga, Cynthia Nixon, Christine Baranski. Lots happens–presumably setting up the second half of the season–with Spector’s business dealings getting rockier, Farmiga’s introduction to England flopping, and Benton making an unpleasant re-acquaintance. Richardson also gets a bunch, and various supporting cast members check in for the subplots. It’s good stuff, but the finish leaves Coon in an all-too-easy villain position.

The Gilded Age (2022) s03e06 “If You Want to Cook an Omelette” [2025] D: Deborah Kampmeier. S: Carrie Coon, Morgan Spector, Louisa Jacobson, Denée Benton, Taissa Farmiga, Cynthia Nixon, Christine Baranski. Inordinately soapy episode–almost all the subplots have an element, except Coon’s trip to England to support Farmiga. That subplot works out fantastic thanks to the acting and Coon not having a villainous demeanor. Lots of commotion for Jacobson and Benton; we’ll see on the Jacobson story, but the Benton one already delivers. Good episode for Nixon, in particular.

The Gilded Age (2022) s03e07 “Ex-Communicated” [2025] D: Salli Richardson-Whitfield. S: Carrie Coon, Morgan Spector, Louisa Jacobson, Denée Benton, Taissa Farmiga, Cynthia Nixon, Christine Baranski. Excellent episode puts all the soap to good effect, with various storylines getting new developments with some big surprises. Great episode for most of the cast, in particular Coon, Nixon, and Jacobson. Blake Ritson gets more showcasing than usual (to excellent effect) before disappearing from the very busy second half. Great direction from Richardson-Whitfield, as usual.

The Gilded Age (2022) s03e08 “My Mind Is Made Up” [2025] D: Salli Richardson-Whitfield. S: Carrie Coon, Morgan Spector, Louisa Jacobson, Denée Benton, Taissa Farmiga, Cynthia Nixon, Christine Baranski. Great season finale resolves a bunch of season threads (and themes) while setting the table for a rather eventful nest season. Baranski finally gets some growth instead of gags, Benton’s got a phenomenal episode, Coon and Spector, too. It keeps the soap suds but they’ve got all sorts of heft. And the gowns are, of course, spectacular.

My Life Is Murder (2019) s05e01 “Gimme An M” [2025] D: . S: Lucy Lawless, Ebony Vagulans, Dean O’Gorman, Iana Grace, Eden Hart, Sally Stockwell, Evander Brown. Lawless and Vagulans are back and investigating the death of a fitness influencer and how his cheerleader girlfriend figures in. Over enthusiastic (character not performance, performance is delightful) Louise Jiang’s cheerleader teammate is trying to undercover the truth. It’s mostly Lawless irritating the suspects, without a lot of outside activity. But great locations and solidly engaging as ever.

My Life Is Murder (2019) s05e02 “Catfish” [2025] D: . S: Lucy Lawless, Ebony Vagulans, Martin Henderson, Jackson Gallagher, Yvie Harvie-Salter, Mike Edward, Xana Tang. Complicated solution to a dead aquarium manager (who ended up in one of the tanks), which includes Lawless considering romancing the prime suspect (studly marine biologist Edward). Martin Henderson’s back–and down on his luck, as usual–as Lawless’s brother, setting up his season arc. Lots of fun with the investigation, too, both surf and turf.

My Life Is Murder (2019) s05e03 “For The Love of Dog” [2025] D: . S: Lucy Lawless, Ebony Vagulans. This episode’s mystery is so complicated Lawless even comments on it. It starts being about dogs, then is about a millionaire dating club, then ends as combination of the two. Vagulans gets a strange arc (as much as anyone gets an arc). It’s okay enough, but the pay-off’s not worth the (intentionally) convoluted trek.

Resident Alien (2021) s04e08 “Mine Town” [2025] D: Nastaran Dibai. S: Alan Tudyk, Sara Tomko, Corey Reynolds, Alice Wetterlund, Levi Fiehler, Elizabeth Bowen, Meredith Garretson. All sorts of plot threads tie together as various revelations have repercussions. Tudyk gets a scene with pretty much everyone, usually to outstanding effect. Good episode for Tomko and Wetterlund, too, but–again–it’d help to lean harder on a Capracorn angle. Oh, and a great episode for Reynolds, who gets a new partner (of sorts).

Resident Alien (2021) s04e09 “Tunnel Vision” [2025] D: Robert Duncan McNeill. S: Alan Tudyk, Sara Tomko, Corey Reynolds, Alice Wetterlund, Levi Fiehler, Elizabeth Bowen, Meredith Garretson. Superb penultimate episode opens with a large set piece conclusion to last episode’s cliffhanger, then reveals this episode’s stakes, which do increase as things progress. McNeill’s direction’s absurdly good, letting the episode get away with gravitas from performances deservedly and not. Gary Farmer’s got a phenomenal showcase. Everything’s beautifully set for next time and the grand finale. Cool.

Resident Alien (2021) s04e10 “The End Is Here” [2025] D: Robert Duncan McNeill. S: Alan Tudyk, Sara Tomko, Corey Reynolds, Alice Wetterlund, Levi Fiehler, Elizabeth Bowen, Meredith Garretson. Okay (enough) series finale gins up a bunch of apparently easily resolvable, somewhat deep-cut conflicts to get away from just doing a farewell episode. But Tudyk and Tomko are both planning on leaving, so there definitely could’ve been more goodbyes than red herrings. Reynolds’s send-off is particularly pat. It doesn’t flop, but doesn’t do much either.

Briefly, Movies (25 August 2025)

The Adventures of Hercules (1985) D: Luigi Cozzi. S: Lou Ferrigno, Milly Carlucci, Sonia Viviani, William Berger, Carla Ferrigno, Claudio Cassinelli, Maria Rosaria Omaggio. Weird but not in a good way sequel has Ferrigno trying to find Zeus’s missing thunderbolts. Despite truly bewildering set pieces and narrative decisions, it’s just too cheap, too poorly made, and too sedate to offer any amusement. Even when it hits extremes. Presumably a Cannon production but the boys left their names off it for some reason.

Blood Quantum (2019) D: Jeff Barnaby. S: Michael Greyeyes, Elle-Máijá Tailfeathers, Forrest Goodluck, Kiowa Gordon, Olivia Scriven, Stonehorse Lone Goeman, Gary Farmer. Not bad idea for a zombie picture–an Indigenous tribe is immune to the zombie plague but everyone (and everything else) is not. Unfortunately, writer, director, and, unfortunately, editor Barnaby can’t make it happen on the dirt-cheap budget. Greyeyes is fine as the “dad” hero (and Goeman’s a hoot as his dad), but otherwise the acting’s… prosumer.

Death to Smoochy (2002) D: Danny DeVito. S: Robin Williams, Edward Norton, Catherine Keener, Danny DeVito, Jon Stewart, Pam Ferris, Michael Rispoli. Delightfully strange “black comedy” version of a Frank Capra with earnest children’s show host Norton taking over for scuzball Williams. Williams goes after Norton, who’s also navigating the mob-backed children’s television industry. Great performances (Williams, Norton, Keener, Ferris), some mid-miscasts, and bewilderingly inept direction from DeVito (who goes for zany). Williams and Norton go all out.

The Fantastic 4: First Steps (2025) D: Matt Shakman. S: Pedro Pascal, Vanessa Kirby, Ebon Moss-Bachrach, Joseph Quinn, Ralph Ineson, Julia Garner, Natasha Lyonne. Narratively rushed, visually spectacular FIRST (fifth, but who’s counting) outing for the Marvel Comics characters. Fine performances from the quartet and frantic enthusiasm keep the ship afloat until the action kicks in to higher and higher gear. Set in the 1960s in an alternate reality (to the Marvel movie universe), there’s no continuity, for better and worse.

Hard Truths (2024) D: Mike Leigh. S: Marianne Jean-Baptiste, Michele Austin, David Webber, Tuwaine Barrett, Ani Nelson, Sophia Brown, Jonathan Livingstone. Absurdly well-acted family drama about Jean-Baptiste’s detoriating mental state. She’s fantastic but showy, while Austin (as her sister) alternates between frustration, confusion, and devastation. Leigh’s intentionality about showing and not telling maintains an intensity throughout, but then the third act calls too much into question without that same thoughtfulness. But peerless acting from the cast. Beautifully done.

Moonlight (2016) D: Barry Jenkins. S: Trevante Rhodes, André Holland, Janelle Monáe, Ashton Sanders, Alex R. Hibbert, Naomie Harris, Mahershala Ali. Wrenching, trending, exhilarating tale of a gay Black man at three stages of life; two childhood, one adult. Fantastic performances all around, with Ali (as a father figure) and Harris (as the troubled mother) inhabiting. Hibbert, Sanders, and Rhodes are outstanding in the lead, with some beautiful character work progressing through. Truly exceptional filmmaking from writer-director Jenkins.

Murder in Greenwich Village (1937) D: Albert S. Rogell. S: Richard Arlen, Fay Wray, Raymond Walburn, Wyn Cahoon, Scott Kolk, Thurston Hall, Marc Lawrence. Murder mystery about society girl Wray getting mixed up with VILLAGE (commercial) artist Arlen. Most of the picture plays like screwball romantic comedy with red herrings instead of gags. Wray and Arlen are game and the production is solid, the script’s just not interested in the actual MURDER. Rogell’s direction could be a lot better, too. But generally fine.

Nancy Drew and the Hidden Staircase (1939) D: William Clemens. S: Bonita Granville, Frankie Thomas, John Litel, Frank Orth, Renie Riano, Vera Lewis, Louise Carter. Final entry in the series adapts the first novel (HIDDEN STAIRCASE), but it’s a lackluster effort. Litel’s barely around, Orth’s back and around way too much. And the stakes are all off (Granville’s ego is keeping old ladies terrified). She and Thomas are still charming, with Thomas getting to do more of the slapstick again. But an inglorious finish.

Nancy Drew… Reporter (1939) D: William Clemens. S: Bonita Granville, John Litel, Frankie Thomas, Dickie Jones, Mary Lee, Larry Williams, Betty Amann. Granville’s competing for a young newspaper reporter award and finds herself a murder investigation to cover. Except then she draws the attention of mysterious character Perry (who’s bewilderingly uncredited despite being the heavy). Thomas, with his great comic timing, reluctantly aids Granville’s investigation. Annoying younger kids Jones and Lee get old fast (and never go away). It’s fine.

Nancy Drew… Trouble Shooter (1939) D: William Clemens. S: Bonita Granville, Frankie Thomas, John Litel, Aldrich Bowker, Charlotte Wynters, Edgar Edwards, Willie Best. When family friend Bowker is falsely accused, lawyer Litel heads to the county to represent him. Litel inexplicably brings Granville, thinking she won’t investigate. She does, but Litel’s too busy romancing Wynters to care. At least until the danger’s too great. It’d be a lot better if Litel weren’t so mean, and there wasn’t the racism directed at Best.

Nancy Drew… Detective (1938) D: William Clemens. S: Bonita Granville, John Litel, James Stephenson, Frankie Thomas, Frank Orth, Helena Phillips Evans, Renie Riano. Engaging outing for Granville (as NANCY) and her faithful sidekick Thomas as they try to discover the whereabouts of mysteriously missing rich lady Evans. Light on actual DETECTIVE work (the bad guys have their own story arc), enthusiasm, Thomas’s well-timed slapstick, and tenacity carry it through. Litel’s good as Granville’s dad, Orth’s distinct (positively?) as the local copper.

The Poseidon Adventure (1972) D: Ronald Neame. S: Gene Hackman, Ernest Borgnine, Red Buttons, Carol Lynley, Roddy McDowall, Stella Stevens, Shelley Winters. Reasonably compelling disaster picture about a capsized ocean liner and the assorted survivors trying to make it to the surface. Dynamite pyrotechniques and production design. Hackman’s renegade preacher (with the personality of a drill instructor) is the leader, bickering constantly with cop Borgnine. Nice support from Winters, Buttons, and Stevens, in particular. The end’s just a tad too flat.

The Survivors (1983) D: Michael Ritchie. S: Robin Williams, Walter Matthau, Jerry Reed, James Wainwright, Kristen Vigard, Joseph Carberry, Anne Pitoniak. Not bad odd couple buddy comedy about yuppie Williams becoming a gun nut, with new pal Matthau unwillingly along for the ride. The third wheel is hit man Reed, who can’t decide if he should kill the duo or befriend them. Even though Reed’s shoehorned in, he helps. Williams can’t handle the second half acting. Matthau saves the day.

The Spirit (November 24, 1940) “The Kidnapping of Ebony”

Will Eisner (editor, script, pencils, inks)

Joe Kubert (colors)

Sam Rosen (letters)

It’s an all-action strip, opening with a thug on the run from the Spirit, desperately clamoring to be let into the hideout. Moments later, the Spirit breaks through the door.

The thugs have kidnapped Ebony in order to lure the Spirit away from his hideout, so they can then torture the location information from Ebony and go plant a couple bodies there. The police will find them and the Spirit will be a wanted man.

Now, as ever, none of the thugs think about just shooting Spirit dead when they have him standing idle, listening to their schemes. Instead, Ebony’s able to get Spirit a pistol—in what, visually, seems to be a racist caricature gag but we’ll not dwell—and so Spirit can start kicking butt.

Despite being restrained for some of it, Ebony plays a big role in that butt-kicking. It’s a good “dynamic duo” strip for Ebony and Spirit. The thugs’ plan is entirely based on their partnership and friendship, and even though Ebony’s not two-fisted like Spirit, he’s got some moves when it comes to putting down the gangsters. And he never squeals, even though they’re torturing him.

Juxtaposed with this extended action sequence is the gang’s seemingly legit boss trying to convince Commissioner Dolan and the mayor to investigate the Spirit’s hideout for bodies. The boss just doesn’t know where the hideout’s located… yet.

The scenes at Dolan’s office—at least after the first one, which sets up the strip—are breaks from the relentless action. And even though it is just action, Eisner and studio turn it up as far as panel composition and choreography. At one point, Ebony is swinging on a hanging light and we get some great POV shots of the floor. Even that opening chase sequence has a lot of angle work. It’s a great looking strip.

Spirit’s such a delight. Minus the occasional Ebony visual cringes.

The Spirit (November 17, 1940) “Dr. Prince Von Kalm”

Will Eisner (editor, script, pencils, inks)

Joe Kubert (colors)

Sam Rosen (letters)

It’s another political intrigue strip, with a European writer arriving in the U.S. after escaping growing fascism in his country. He’s immediately confronted by secret police from his country, who taunt him with the news they’ve captured his daughter and will execute her unless she returns. So he plans to return immediately, but not quick enough the Spirit doesn’t confront him and offer a plan. What if the Spirit poses as the writer, goes in his place, and gets the daughter out?

Being an American, the Spirit doesn’t give the writer any choice in the situation, and they start prepping Spirit for the mission.

Once in the (fictional) European country, the disguised Spirit has a brief meeting with the daughter—long enough to discover the country’s dictator isn’t going to free her in exchange as promised—and then goes about breaking out of his cell. There are a couple escape-related gags, with Eisner and studio hurrying things along so they can get to the action.

In addition to escaping the guards in the palace, Spirit’s going to have to do some swashbuckling, some flying, and some reassuring (the daughter has never heard of the Spirit, being a European gal and all). There’s also the “world domination plans,” which Spirit and the daughter decide to grab before they leave, leading to a few more panels.

The strip moves briskly, never slowing down too much for an action sequence, though clearly reveling in the swashbuckler sequence. It’s a good sequence. They’ve also got the Spirit in disguise for a good few pages of the strip, leading to the disconcerting moment when they do some beefcake of Spirit punching his way around the castle. It’s fun stuff, if a little slight. This one’s how you do the overt jingoism (save the obnoxious American superiority business, obviously).

The last page is mostly post-resolution, with Ebony getting his own quick adventure. However, it does draw attention to the strip not knowing what to do with supporting cast when the Spirit’s ostensibly on a six week mission and whatnot.

Minor gripe for an otherwise solid strip. And it’s not like the finale isn’t amusing, it’s just… nonsensical, too.

The Spirit (November 10, 1940) “The Kiss of Death”

Will Eisner (editor, script, pencils, inks)

Joe Kubert (colors)

Sam Rosen (letters)

The Black Queen’s back again, this time fully in her supervillain period, wearing a skimpy outfit and a cape. Far cry from when she was a “notorious female mouthpiece.” But also a far cry from her scheming in the shadows to take over the city with an army of gangsters.

Now she’s just seducing men, getting them to betray their employers (and wives), then killing them for good measure. With killer lipstick, something Commissioner Dolan really should figure out before the last page of the strip.

It’s mostly an action strip. After some setup with Black Queen and the connection between her victims, Spirit starts chasing her, and then there are only occasional interruptions to their action sequences. They have a big showdown on a bridge, with Eisner and studio getting to do a lot with the angles not to mention the actual fisticuffs (or whatever the equivalent since Spirit doesn’t want to hit a lady).

While Black Queen becoming a supervillain is certainly a surprise character development (especially since her plotting has downshifted from robbing the federal reserve to robbing a jeweler), the strip’s got so many great moments one doesn’t slow down to think it through especially since there’s so much humor running through it.

One of Dolan’s cops is convinced—always—the Spirit has done it. So every once in a while, someone will have to remind him, but no, it’s obviously not the Spirit. But the recurring humor gag works, especially once it’s clear they’re not giving it up just because Spirit didn’t do it.

There’s also some “Spirit invents” this strip, with suction cup shoes playing into the chase sequence at one point. Again, despite Black Queen putting on a leather bikini, a cape, and some stilettos—it’s a great kitchen sink of Spirit. There’s personality from Dolan (contending with his dimmer bulbs), Spirit getting in some banter, and a nice “first act” setting things up.

And the art, obviously. The art’s so dang good. And the exposition’s working on getting witty, too.

All-Star Comics (1976) #63

Paul Levitz (assistant editor, script)

Keith Giffen (layouts)

Wally Wood (pencils, inks)

Al Sirois (inks)

Carl Gafford (colors)

Ben Oda (letters)

Joe Orlando (editor)

Paul Levitz takes over the full writing gig, no longer only dialoguing from a plot, and… well, at least there’s not all the misogyny. Otherwise, there’s not much improvement. It’s definitely somewhat different—we get lots of heroes standing around moping about how they can’t possibly be heroes when there’s so much against them. Dr. Mid-Nite quits, and so does someone else (who’s quit at least once before in All-Star, with Levitz using it for the same story beat again). And the whole thing is supposed to be about how Dr. Fate’s on death’s door.

If only there were a deus ex machina to resolve it. Unexpectedly, it comes a page after filler about Green Lantern and the Flash being in Egypt—at Fate’s subconscious request—to find a cure. There’s also a silly bit with Flash making fun of “mystics,” even though Dr. Fate’s a literal sorcerer and Green Lantern has a magic ring. It’s not so much the internal logic of All-Star not making sense, it’s Levitz not even acknowledging it should.

The issue opens with a big fight scene involving Hawkman, Wildcat, Solomon Grundy, and the Fiddler. The Fiddler has brainwashed Wildcat into beating Hawkman to death. Despite the promises he’s killed him, Hawkman is, in fact, fine. The exposition goes on and on about Wildcat’s fatal fists, but apparently, he didn’t do much actual damage. As the fight resolves, we find out in addition to Wildcat misunderstanding how killing Hawkman (or anyone) works, we find out the JSA has been operating under the assumption Superman and Power Girl are dead from last issue.

They are not.

Wildcat then makes it sound like they just let Superman do all the actual work and wait to see what he’s come up with. With all these heroics on display, what can the rest of the issue hold? Not much aside from the aforementioned moping about not being heroic like in the old days, some oddly static fight scenes (with nice detail from Wally Wood, just not a lot of energy).

The various stakes of the issue—including the supervillains trying to kill the JSA—either get punted or resolved off-page. Hawkman’s “Real Men Could Save Their Wives” arc is another page-burner. Levitz hasn’t got any actual material, just gristle.

The various setups for next time don’t promise much, either. More mysteries, more supervillain plotting, presumably the same contrived plotting.

Levitz doesn’t distinguish himself as the solo writer yet. And doesn’t do anything to imply he will.

The Spirit (November 3, 1940) “The Manly Art of Self Defense”

Will Eisner (editor, script, pencils, inks)

Joe Kubert (colors)

Sam Rosen (letters)

The splash page is Ellen Dolan with a black eye, reading The Manly Art of Self Defense. Given Ellen’s last appearance in the strip, it’s a sensational and not unconcerning opener. But it’ll all work out, with Self Defense possibly the best Spirit strip so far.

We open in Wildwood Cemetery, Spirit running into the crypt, begging Ebony to hide him. Ebony wonders what could have the Spirit so scared… why, it’s just Ellen Dolan. She’s told the Spirit she loves him and he’s run away. She decides to catch a criminal to prove herself worthy of his attention.

Except the criminal she goes to catch is dead, and an enforcer is just arriving to find her there. Luckily, the Spirit convinces the thug Ellen’s not the killer, except she then wants to identify herself as the commissioner’s daughter, which would complicate matters.

The Spirit will eventually find the killer, defeat the gangsters, and generally save the day. Ellen will get that black eye. And, then, in the glorious last page, pay the shiner back in full. Along the way, there are multiple action and suspense sequences. The line work is gorgeous, as are all the shadowy panels. Eisner and studio really go for mood this strip and it pays off. They also play with color in the last action scene, setting it in the dark (blue), and it’s a dynamite visual. The Spirit’s got a lot of gangsters to get through before the day’ll be saved. The strip’s seven pages, not including the splash, and three of those pages are superlative. The flow between the panels, the change in angles and distance, the expressions, the fisticuffs… it’s all just fantastic.

But what will put it over is how the strip deals with that first plot line—Spirit and Ellen—things have gotten a little more complicated and there’s not exactly a lot of time to wrap it. Still, Eisner leaves the couple’s relationship in a far more interesting place than it’s ever been before. And without being crappy to Ellen.

Maybe minus her naïveté in going after the criminal at the beginning (the strip has forgotten she’s in school to be a criminal psychologist or whatever).

Anyway.

Manly’s a beautiful piece of work.

The Spirit (October 27, 1940) “Conscription Bill Signed”

Will Eisner (editor, script, pencils, inks)

Joe Kubert (colors)

Sam Rosen (letters)

It’s a good thing Spirit cleared his name since he needs Dolan’s official recommendation this strip.

FDR has just signed the Selective Training and Service Act—a peacetime draft—and, being a good jingoist, the Spirit wants to sign up. He’s got some conditions, however. He doesn’t want to reveal his identity and he wants to be put to good use (based on his skills).

The Army thinks he’ll make a good espionage agent, especially when the Spirit immediately uncovers a spy in the Army recruitment office. As a try-out for the Army, he roots out the rest of the spies, who call him “Americano” but also have guys named Adolf. Spirit still isn’t willing to be specific about which foreign powers are the baddies.

The action’s pretty straightforward, with Spirit tracking the bad guys back to their hideout and taking them out. He’s got Ebony along for backup, so there’s some comedy action involving Ebony flying the autoplane and seeing trouble on the ground.

Dolan’s particularly pissy about Spirit this strip. Dolan’s jealous about Spirit breaking all the big cases, a bit of character development Eisner’s had on a slow boil for a while now, though it never made sense when Dolan was lowkey protecting the Spirit from the rest of the police force.

The jealousy just leads to banter—and whining—as the Army comes to realize having the Spirit on the payroll will work out, after all.

While it’s an interesting attempt at being timely—though the draft was for twenty-one to forty-five and the Spirit says it’s just until thirty-five, so they needed some copy-editing—it’s also just propaganda. At times well-illustrated propaganda, to be sure, but there’s no oompf to the story.

And Spirit mansplaining the United States being the only place on Earth where a man can live in freedom and peace to Ebony (thankfully in long shot in one of those pretty propaganda panels) is one hell of a flex.

The Spirit (October 20, 1940) “Ogre Goran”

Will Eisner (editor, script, pencils, inks)

Joe Kubert (colors)

Sam Rosen (letters)

It’s another slighter strip, with the Spirit rescuing a damsel in distress from her ex (the titular Ogre Goran), a psychopath who’s just escaped prison.

The opening is the prison break and it’s relatively solid business. The line work is wanting this strip, but the moody long shots of the action are still effective. The action shifts to the damsel, Mary, discussing Ogre’s prison break with her husband. Since it’s a comic strip, Ogre appears immediately following her statement, shooting her husband dead on the spot and ready to kidnap her. Luckily, Mary dowses him in alcohol and sets him (and the apartment) on fire.

Now, we know Ogre gets away because he gets in the shower and turns on the cold water. Also, there’s a panel (maybe the least discernible in the series to date) of Ogre getting away.

Fast forward a few days to Ebony trying to get the Spirit interested in the case. After initially discounting Ebony’s thoughts on Ogre’s survival (Spirit thought the shower was only running because someone wanted a bath), the Spirit agrees with Ebony’s conclusions—Ogre’s alive!

The Spirit tries to find Mary, only to learn she’s gone away with a man entirely wrapped in bandages. Ogre, post-burns. Thanks to Commissioner Dolan giving him information about Ogre’s old hideouts, Spirit heads (by boat) to an abandoned lighthouse where Ogre’s got to be holding Mary. Dolan heads to the lighthouse, too, wanting to beat the Spirit to the punch.

Spirit’s only cleared his “name” of a murder charge in last week’s strip, so Dolan competing with him doesn’t make much sense. It also doesn’t make sense how Spirit gets to the lighthouse by boat, but then his boat disappears and he can’t take it back to shore at the end of the strip.

Also nonsensical is Ogre having a new wife, who can—presumably, more appropriately—beat up Mary.

We don’t even get to see Spirit and Ogre’s fisticuffs.

Not a lot of pay-off in the strip, though it’s nice to see Ebony developing as a sidekick.

It’s also the dottiest the art’s been in ages. The line work gains slide back here.