The Stop Button

blogging by Andrew Wickliffe

recent posts

Supergirl 2 (December 2011)

235966_20111019160454_large.jpg
Oh, I’m going to regret saying it… but this issue of Supergirl isn’t bad. If it weren’t for some of the art issues, it might even be good.

It’s an all-action issue (again), with Kara and Clark fighting it out over Russia and China. The location makes it a novel idea, but there’s also all this talking, with Clark trying to calm her down and whatnot.

And in those moments, Asrar and Green (and colorist Dave McCaig, can’t forget him here), make this great Supergirl comic. Sure, her costume is still moronic. Asrar doesn’t objectify her, but her costume does? It doesn’t make any sense conceptually and it’s visually confused.

But Asrar’s Superman is awful. Superman looks about fourteen and bears a striking resemblance to “Alfalfa” Switzer. The bad Superman does these moments in.

Green and Johnson actually pleasantly surprised me. I was dreading this issue, but it’s fine.

CREDITS

Reunion; writers, Michael Green and Mike Johnson; penciller, Mahmud Asrar; inker, Dan Green; colorist, Dave McCaig; letterer, John J. Hill; editors, Matt Idelson and Wil Moss; publisher, DC Comics.

Posted in ,

One response to “Supergirl 2 (December 2011)”

  1. Vernon Wiley Avatar
    Vernon Wiley

    After two issues of action sequences drawn out WAY more than necessary, I am losing patience for this book. The artist is decent, if not spectacular, but the string thick plot could have been done in one (not that THAT would have been distinctive), and you still don’t have much to build an audience with here. I still don’t have any resonance for the character, and still after two issues am encouraged to read a third. It’s only other hope at this point is to be a stroke book, and I don’t see it succeeding at that either.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.