234580_20110921191123_large.jpg
Relaunching Supergirl when Superman’s not even established seems thoughtless. Thank goodness writers Michael Green and Mike Johnson are so dull they don’t even engage that question.

Their take on Supergirl is she’s a dumb teenage girl. If they made her like Paris Hilton–someone who turned herself into a brand–it might be interesting. Instead, she’s just a dumb girl.

They do, however, lift moments from Supreme Power and Red Son; their lack of ingenuity is universal, not just Kara.

DC should have hired a female writer. Or at least hired a guy with a teenage daughter. Green and Johnston’s insight into the female condition isn’t laughable. It would need to exist to be laughable.

Mahmud Asrar’s art is actually pretty good. There’s no reasonable explanation for Supergirl to dress like a hooker out of Blade Runner (except DC likes objectifying teenage girls). But Asrar probably didn’t do the redesign….

CREDITS

Last Daughter of Krypton; writers, Michael Green and Mike Johnson; penciller, Mahmud Asrar; inkers, Dan Green and Asrar; colorist, Dave McCaig; letterer, John J. Hill; editors, Matt Idelson and Wil Moss; publisher, DC Comics.

Posted in ,

One response to “Supergirl 1 (November 2011)”

  1. Vernon Wiley Avatar

    I may be wrong, but I believe Jim Lee was entrusted to do the “uniform tweaks” on many of the DC characters. Some really hideous designs can be found as back matter in the 1st JLA. Why they wanted to reproduce these other than to fill pages is beyond me. The biggest fault of SG#1 for me was the twenty page extended scene of a comic. No plot, no story, just twenty pages of a long, drawn out scene that was pretty dull to begin with. The artist was decent, but this Supergirl looks to be in her mid twenties rather than a girl. This “comic” produces yet another failure from the reboot. The insult that this tripe comes after a really good run on the character by Sterling Gates and Jamal Igle is all the more astounding. DC publish comics? Nah, these are just place sitters, advertising the brand name for possible licensing. Comic readers need not apply.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.